Sunday, 11 December 2011

Wailing woes of Kashmiri women

By : Saeed ur Rehman Siddiqui

Inspite of the fact that the violations of human rights in Kashmir are in direct disregard to the principles of international human rights, humanitarian laws including the Geneva Conventions and the protocols additional thereto, no attention has been directed to address the issue at national and international levels. An appropriate response is necessitated by the fact that the violations of human rights in Kashmir's armed conflict have had a direct bearing on its civilian population. Civilian victims, mostly women and children, often outnumber casualties among the combatants [1]. But women suffer in both differing and complex forms. They suffer directly by being subject to rape, molestation and torture and others whose relations are subject to atrocities suffer because of being related to them. It therefore becomes imperative to try and analyse the impact that the past 18 years of conflict have had on Kashmiri women. More so, because there needs to be an awareness and understanding that armed conflict and its impact affect women physically, psychologically, socially and economically [2]. The International Committee of The Red Cross (ICRC) places the impact of armed conflict on women under eight themes: Displacement, security, sexual violence, missing persons, detention, access to medicare, access to food and other assistance and protection under international humanitarian law [3].

Rape cases

A study done by Medecins Sans Frontieres in mid 2005 reveals that Kashmiri women are among the worst sufferers of sexual violence in the world. It further mentions that since the beginning of the armed struggle in Kashmir in 1989, sexual violence has been routinely perpetrated on Kashmiri women, with 11.6 per cent of respondents saying they were victims of sexual abuse. Interestingly, the figure is much higher than that of Sierra Leone, Sri Lanka and Chechnya. The state home department has no specific data in this regard for the last 17 years. This serves as a telling comment on the plight of women and on the indifferent attitude of the state towards addressing the issue. Cases of rape and molestation abound in Kashmir and many go unreported because of the fear of social stigma, and of reprisal by state agencies. And even in those cases, where the victims manage to transcend these fears and report the matter to police, they achieve little or no justice. More often, police refuses to lodge an FIR against the troops.

In Kunan Poshpora, a small village in Kashmir, the soldiers of fourth Rajputana Rifles allegedly raped about 30 women on the night of February 23, 1991, during a search operation while men were taken away from their homes and interrogated. The ages of women raped ranged from 13 to 80 years. According to newspaper reports, on June 17,1994, troops of Rashtriya Rifles accompanied by two officers Major Ramesh and Major Rajkumar entered into village Hyhama and allegedly raped and molested seven women. In another incident, troops raped a mentally ill old woman in her house in Barbarshah in Srinagar on January 5, 1991. Medical reports confirmed rape and locals lodged an FIR with the concerned police station, but the police did no investigation. She later died in 1998 while the FIR still awaits action from the state government. In another gruesome incident, an army Major in Badra, Handwara, raped Aisha, a 29-year-old woman and her 10-year-old daughter, Shabnum. These being just a few examples, incidents like these are plenty in Kashmir and ironically pass unheeded for.

Due to immunity of troops from prosecution and their own court martial proceedings, which are far from being unbiased, they are left free to do as they please. Dr Maiti, a professor of political science at Rurdwa University, West Bengal, explains, "Rape continues to be a major instrument of Indian oppression against the Kashmiri people while the majority of victims are civilians. This concept stands fortified by a report of ICRC dated March 6, 2001, where it has been mentioned that women are raped in order to humiliate, frighten and defeat the enemy 'group' to which they belong. Rape in a war is not merely a matter of chance; it is rather a question of power and control, which is 'structured by male soldiers' notions of their masculine privilege, by the strength of the military line of command and by class and ethnic inequalities among women [4]. One of the reasons given by Radhika Coomaraswamy for sexual violence in armed conflict is that violence against women may be directed towards the social group of which she is a member because 'to rape a woman is to humiliate her community'. Complex and combined emotions of hatred, superiority, vengeance for real or imagined wrongs and national pride are engendered and deliberately manipulated in armed conflict. For the men of the community, rape encapsulates the totality of their defeat; they have failed to protect their women [5]. The Special Rapporteur appointed by the United Nations Commission on Human Rights in former Yugoslavia termed rape as not only as an instrument of war but as a method of ethnic cleansing intended to humiliate, shame, degrade and terrify the entire ethnic group [6].

A study done by Medecins Sans Frontieres in mid 2005 reveals that Kashmiri women are among the worst sufferers of sexual violence in the world. Interestingly, the figure is much higher than that of Sierra Leone, Sri Lanka and Chechnya

The Geneva Convention related to The Protection of Civilian Persons In Times Of War, 1949 and Additional Protocols of 1977 provide that women shall especially be protected against humiliating and degrading treatment; rape, enforced prostitution or any form of indecent assault [7]. The Vienna Declaration and Programme Of Action adopted by the World Conference on Human Rights in Situations of Armed Conflict states that violations of human rights of women in situations of armed conflict are violations of the fundamental principles of international human rights and humanitarian law. Even though states are under an obligation to make grave breaches of Geneva Conventions and protocols additional thereto subject to the jurisdiction of their own courts and punishable by severe penalties. The domestic courts do not peruse the law laid down under the said convention for rape trials in conflict areas like Kashmir. However, rape is not explicitly listed as a grave breach of Geneva Convention, although acts willfully committed and causing great suffering or causing grave injury to body or health do constitute breaches.

The fact that rape has been systematically committed against Kashmiri women and that justice has not been delivered in these cases makes rape in Kashmir eligible for an appropriate legal response at the international level. The state has to be held for breach of its obligations under various relevant treaties and customary international law.

The prosecution of individuals alleged to have committed rape should be done by the international criminal tribunal on the precedent of Nuremberg as the domestic courts and military court-martials have failed to deliver justice in these matters and are motivated by a state centric approach [8]. The focus of the tribunal should be to punish the wrongdoers, not on providing compensation and support to the victim.

The International tribunals are unique in that, they can be established during the continuation of the conflict and therefore they are untainted by the notions of 'victors justice'. Prosecutions must be brought against the alleged perpetrators and those higher up in the chain of command [9].

Rape is a grave crime as its consequences extend beyond the actual commission, often lasting for the rest of the life of a woman [10]. The social stigma associated with rape renders a raped woman unmarriageable, deprived of respect in the society and traumatised for the rest of her life. In some cases women become unacceptable even to their own families. The necessity to bring the perpetrators of rapes in Kashmir to justice can be understood from the fact that parties to conflict often rape as a tactic of war and terrorism [11].


Half-widows of the Valley

Enforced disappearance is one of the most harrowing consequences of the armed conflict in Kashmir. During the last 18 years of conflict, the Association Of Parents Of Disappeared Persons (APDP) [12], an organisation of the relatives of people who have disappeared after custody, claims more than 10,000 people have been subject to enforced disappearance by state agencies and were mostly picked up by the troops. Of the disappeared persons, between 2000-2005 a majority were married males. Although men have been subject to disappearance largely, but women have been adversely affected because of being related to them as daughters, mothers, sisters and wives. In the absence of any information about the whereabouts of the disappeared men, their wives have acquired the title of ' half-widows'. These half-widows apart from other relatives of disappeared persons are left without any entitlement to land, homes, inheritance, social assistance and pensions. Most of these women also suffer from harassment by the troops.

Fahmeeda Bano, 37, lives in a remote Kashmir village of Kupwara and 14 years back the Indian army picked up her husband. She has gone from pillar to post searching for him but to no avail. She said, "If my husband is alive I want to see him. I want authorities to tell me where he is. If he has been killed let them hand over his body to me..."

The Indian government does not provide any relief to half-widows before the expiry of seven years from the date of disappearance. And even after the completion of seven years from the date of disappearance, they get either a one-time grant ranging from US$1,000 and US$2,000 or a monthly pension of US$10 [13]. Further, a half-widow cannot remarry until the expiration of seven years from the date of disappearance of her husband whose whereabouts must not be known in these seven years. In the meantime, the right to her husband's property are often threatened. Some widows, who intend to remarry, largely do not find men who are willing to marry them. A study titled, 'Women And Children Under The Armed Conflict In Kashmir' done by Prof A G Madhosh, a Kashmiri educationist and activist, reveals that the migration of widows with their children resulted in a sudden break in normal family life. Women had to assume the roles of breadwinners for their families and the future of their children became insecure.

Every month the members of APDP gather for a sit-in-protest at Central Park in Srinagar. Their continuous protests should have served as a resonating alarm for the authorities, but they seem to have turned a deaf ear to the woes of these people. Fahmeeda Bano, 37, lives in a remote Kashmir village of Kupwara and 14 years back the Indian army picked up her husband. She has gone from pillar to post searching for him but to no avail. She said, "If my husband is alive I want to see him. I want authorities to tell me where he is. If he has been killed let them hand over his body to me. [14]"

Psychological Impact

With killings, torture, rapes, molestations, disappearances and detentions becoming the order of the day in Kashmir, psychiatric disorders have seen a sharp increase post-1989. In 1989, about 1,700 patients visited the valley's lone psychiatric hospital and by the year 2003, the number had gone up to 48,000. Before the onset of the armed struggle, certain disorders that were not known to Kashmiris started showing a significant presence amongst the civilian population. The Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PSTD), one of the psychiatric diseases, which was completely unrecognised before 1990 has witnessed a major upsurge. Major Depressive Disorder (MDO) follows this. There are other mental diseases like bipolar disorder, panic, phobia; general anxiety and sleep disorders that have also shown four-fold increase as told by Dr Arshad of the Psychiatric Diseases Hospital in Srinagar. Substance Use Disorder or drug addiction and suicidal tendencies has been another repercussion of the ongoing conflict in Kashmir. Dr Arshad further added that the patients who come to seek help are largely in the productive age group of 25-30 years [15]. Dr Mushtaq Marghoob, a leading psychiatrist of the valley states that women bear the brunt of every tragedy. They have to support the family after the death of their husbands, fathers, sons or brothers. Dr Arshad further adds that women form a major part of the patients who are suffering from PSTD (almost 50 per cent). For women whose husbands have died, psychotherapy has failed to produce desired results.


A woman from Batmaloo, Srinagar saw the body of her brother who was killed in custody by soldiers of the Indian army, the body had been split open and his heart had been taken out. The shock rendered her in a state of disturbed bereavement and PSTD ever since. According to Dr Marghoob, women have become increasingly suicidal and are resorting to sleeping pills, injections and inhalations [16]. Even though a large number of people visit the Psychiatric Diseases Hospital in Srinagar, however, this is only a tip of the iceberg as large numbers of patients visit hospitals at the district and sub-district levels.

Nearly every person, particularly women, suffer from general anxiety and the uncertainty pertaining to the security of their family members. This always keep them in a state of unrest and anxiety. Even in their houses people are harassed, beaten up or taken into custody by the troops. The fact that the situation doesn't seem to get any better, doesn't promise a better mental state of the civilian population, especially women, in Kashmir.

In past few years, murders, rapes, torture, custodial deaths, and enforced disappearances have witnessed an upsurge, but the response of the state in addressing these atrocities doesn't promise hope for justice. The official figures of these atrocities are far too less than the reported ones. The factual human rights situation in Kashmir has always been rendered invisible by the national security concerns of the government and the state centric approach of the Indian media [17]. Living in this environment of hopelessness, there are people like Parveena who are still willing to give a tough fight to powers-that-be. Parveena says, "I am determined to fight till my last breath, with or without anyone's support". People like Parveena need to be lauded for their determination.

It is being constantly projected in the mainstream media that the situation in Kashmir has improved, but the ever-increasing rate of human rights violations in the valley tell us a different story. People continue to suffer while the much-hyped slogan of Prime Minister Manmohan Singh proclaiming 'Zero Tolerance' towards human rights abuse stares him hard in the face!

REFERENCES

1. UN Fourth World Conference On Women, Beijing-China, September 1995.

2. UN Commission on Human Rights; Sub Commission on the Promotion and Protection Of Human Rights, Fifty Fifth Session, Item 6(a) of the provisional agenda.

3. ICRC, March 6, 2001.

4. Christine Chinkin; Rape and Sexual Abuse of Women in International Law. European Journal of International Law.

5. R Coomaraswamy; 'Of Kali Born; Violence and the Law in Sri Lanka'; In M Schuler (ed), Freedom Of Violence; Women's Strategies from Around The World.

6. Tadeusz Mazowiecki, Special Rapporteur of the Commission on Human Rights, Report pursuant to Commission Resolution 1992/S-1/1/ 0f 14 August 1992, E/CN/4/1993/50/10 February 1993.

7. UN Fourth World Conference On Women; Beijing-China; Strategic Objective 144(C); Governments should fully respect norms of International Humanitarian Law in armed conflicts and take all measures required for the protection of women and children in particular against rape, forced prostitution and any other form of indecent assault.

8. Strategic Objective 143(C), UN 4th World Conference On Women; Beijing-China, Sept 1995: Governments should take action to investigate and punish members of the police, security and armed forces and others who perpetrate acts of violence against women, violations of humanitarian law and violations of the human rights of women in situations of armed conflict.

9. In ' Re Yamashita' 327 USI, 6 Section 340 (United States Supreme Court 1946) the accused was charged that as commander of the armed forces of Japan…he unlawfully disregarded and failed to discharge his duty as commander to control the operations of the members of his command, permitting them to commit brutal atrocities. Although Yamashita was not physically present during the commission of the atrocities, he was found guilty.

10. The Supreme Court of India has ruled in a case that rape is a graver crime than murder as murder kills a person only once, while rape kills a woman again and again.


May Peace Prevail on Earth. May Peace Prevail in Kashmir

Published @ Kashmir Newz

Human Rights Day comes and goes, Kashmir suffers in silence

By : Ishfaq-ul-Hassan

Haneefa Akhthar (name changed), 23, wanted to forget the horror of her past when she got married last year. Destiny, however, had other things in store for her: Haneefa’s husband divorced her just six months after marriage because of social stigma and the gynecological problem she suffered during torture in Indian police custody.

Haneefa was allegedly kicked in her abdomen during interrogation in the Indian force's custody when she was a ninth class student in 2004. “I have got 22 stitches in my abdomen. I suffered blood loss as my uterus was impaired due to the kicking by the Indian officer,” she said

The Indian forces had allegedly picked her up suspecting her of knowing one of the boys accused of killing of a resident of her village in Kupwara district.

She later approached the state human rights commission, which awarded Rs 75,000 compensation to them. “But the police officers were not even touched,” she lamented.

Haneefa’s case is just the tip of the iceberg of human rights abuses in the strife-torn state.

Take the case of 51-year-old Manzoor Ahmad Naikoo of Pahalallan-Pattan who was tortured to the extent that his genitals were burnt and stick inserted into his rectum making him debilitated permanently.

Naikoo, a shopkeeper, was picked up during an army crackdown in his village in 1991 when he was 30.

“They demanded a gun from me. I pleaded that I am shopkeeper but they did not listen. I was taken to a government school building where they first stripped me then tied a cloth on my genitals and set it on fire. Later they dipped my head into a bucket of water and inserted a stick into my rectum,” he said.

The worst was yet to come. Some youth mustered courage and took him to hospital where colostomy procedure was done so that he could pass stool through a hole made in his abdomen. “For the last 21 years, my abdomen is having a hole which leaks stool. I though cover it with my cotton but I can’t go anywhere,” he said.
Naikoo approached the court which directed the state and the Centre to pay Rs 5 lakh compensation. “But the culprits have not been brought to book,” said the father of three.


Human rights groups say the police and security forces use torture as an instrument to choke the voice of dissent in the state. “Torture is widespread in Kashmir which has gone unreported. Torture has made people permanently disabled,” said Khurram Parvez, programme coordinator Jammu and Kashmir Coalition of Civil Society.

Published @ DNA

Tuesday, 15 November 2011

FIR & Chronology of Attacks on Syed Ali Shah Geelani


FIR & Chronology of Attacks on Syed Ali Shah Geelani

To

The Station House Officer,
Police Station Sopore.

Subject: Registration of an FIR.

In a peaceful rally of Syed Ali Geelani in Iqbal Market Sopore on 11-11-2011 a suspicious person was caught hold by the people. By the Intervention of Syed Geelani he was handed over to the police with a hope that matter will be probed into thoroughly. Instead of probing the matter, the SP Sopore as per news report of Greater Kashmir dated 12-11-2011 had stated that the gunman belonged to army intelligence wing and he had gone to rally to record Geelani’s Speech and that he has been admitted in a hospital.

Today i.e. on 13th of November 2011 the daily Greater Kashmir has reported that as per army Naik Kamlesh Kumar Mishra was a member of a covert team of Army and State Police and had been sent to Sopore to gather information of the presence of terrorists in the public rally. The news paper has however further reported that as per police they were not a part of any joint intelligence operation at Sopore during Geelani’s rally and that intelligence operations are not carried out by the police jointly with the army.

From the aforesaid sequence of events it’s fully established that Naik Kumlesh Kumar Mishra and army personnel had gone to Mr. Geelani’s rally on 11-11-2011 with a pistol and he was not part of any covert operation. He had been perhaps sent by some agency to target Mr. Geelani, but for the timely intervention of the people he couldn’t succeed in his nefarious design. He has been a part of some deep rooted conspiracy hatched by the army intelligence to eliminate Mr. Geelani and it is with that objective that he had come all the way from Srinagar or from elsewhere to attend the rally. The claim of Army that he was a part of a covert team of army and police having been rejected by the police the matter appears to be very grave and serious.
You are accordingly requested to register an FIR in the matter so that the conspiracy hatched to eliminate Mr. Syed Ali Geelani is unearthed and the conspirators as well as the perpetrators of crime are brought to book.
Yours Faithfully

Ayaz Akbar
Spokesman
All Parties Hurriyat Conference Jammu and Kashmir

Copies news items of Greater Kashmir are enclosed herewith.

Greater Kashmir dated 12-11-2011 on page 10

YOUTH NABBED WITH PISTOL

An unidentified youth allegedly carrying a pistol was beaten to pulp by people on the suspicion of being personnel of some government agency during Syed Ali Shah Geelani’s rally in Sopore on Friday.
Soon after Geelani concluded his speech, an unidentified youth was caught by the people and severely thrashed.

The spokesperson of Tehreek-i-Hurriyat, Ayaz Akbar, said the youth was from some government agency and a pistol was also found in his possession. He said it was only after Geelani’s intervention that the youth was set free. He condemned the presence of an armed personal during public gathering that too with a weapon.

“The person could have made attempt on the life of Geelani sahib or intended to disrupt the public gathering,” Ayaz Akbar said.

Greater Kashmir dated 13-11-2011

Army confirms soldier’s presence in Geelani rally

PRESS TRUST OF INDIA

Srinagar, Nov 12: The Army has said the man who was beaten up by mob on suspicion that he had made an assassination bid on Hurriyat (G) chairman Syed Ali Shah Geelani during a rally here was actually a member of its "covert team".

"An army man was beaten up by mob due to mistaken identity (in the public rally addressed by Geelani yesterday). His service pistol, identity card and mobile were snatched by them," a defence spokesman said here in a statement.

A "covert team" of army and state police was sent to Sopore, 55 kms from here, to gather information on the presence of "terrorists" in the public rally, he said.
Hurriyat (G) had yesterday claimed an assassination attempt was made on Geelani by a man carrying a pistol who was nabbed by people at the rally.
"The man was nabbed when he was asked to show his identity card at the rally...Why would a man come to a rally with a pistol. It could possibly have been an attempt to target Geelani," Hurriyat spokesman Ayaz Akbar had said.

The defence spokesperson said, "The man, seriously injured, was rescued by his colleagues, and admitted to the army hospital...A case has been lodged by the army against the miscreants."

GKNN ADDS: Meanwhile, police claimed that they were not part of any joint intelligence operation in Sopore town during Geelani’s rally to nab militants.

Highly placed sources in Jammu and Kashmir Police said that intelligence operations are not carried out jointly.

They said an FIR lodged by army in Sopore police station doesn’t mention the role of police anywhere.

Hurriyat Conference (G) chairman Syed Ali Shah Geelani rebutted the Army claim, saying the MI personnel was released by youth on his intervention.
“These are concocted and baseless claims. They first claimed that the MI personnel was present in the rally for gathering reports and now they say he was there to nab a militant. This shows how much truth is in their claims,” he said.

He said after the Friday prayers his rally passed off peacefully as he had changed the venue to avoid clashes of youth with CRPF men at Main Chowk.
“When I was leaving the rally venue, some youth told me that they had caught an Army personnel. I asked them to release him and they promptly acted upon my advice,” Geelani added.

=================================================

Here is brief chronology of the attacks on the life of Syed Ali Geelani, Chairman All Parties Hurriyat Conference and Tahreek-e-Hurriyat Jammu Kashmir.

In less than 36 hours on May 1996, two attacks were made on the life of Syed Ali Geelani, Senior leader of Jammu and Kashmir Mr. Geelani was targeted eight times by the Indian Forces and India backed renegade militants with the aim to eliminate him from the political scene of Jammu and Kashmir. There have been several attempts on the lives of other All Parties Hurriyat Conference leaders (APHC) too.

1.Oct. 30, 1995: A powerful attack on official residence at Hyderpora.
The attack severely damaged the outer wall and the ground floor of the
building, first floor catching fire. The windowpane of the houses in
an area of about one-kilometer was shattered.

2.Dec. 31, 1995: Indian Regular Forces along with some renegade
militants barged into the residence at Hyderpora with the aim to kill
the leader. Mr. Gee1ani along with his family members remained locked
in a room. The neighbors informed the police and other people. After
an hour they left before they were heard of saying that the mission
was exposed.

3.Dec 10, 1995: The houses of the two brothers of Syed A1i Shah
Gee1ani namely Syed Mirak Shah and Syed Wali Muhammad Shah of Dooru
Sopore were set on fire in broad daylight by the army and their agents
working in the area. The residential house of Syed A1i Shah Geelani
was also partially damaged.

4.Dec 18, 1995: The same house of Syed Ali Shah Geelani was blasted
and raised to the ground.

5.Jan 1, 1996: Task Force (SOG) of Jammu and Kashmir police raided the
official premises and extensively searched the house for two hours.
Nothing incriminating was found. It was believed that they had come to
survey the areas.

6.March 26, 1996: A powerful explosion severely damaged the front wall
of the first floor; the window and doors were shattered.
7.April 9, 1996: A grenade attacks on the western side of the
premises. No damage.

8.May 9, 1996: Firing on the Hurriyat cavalcade at a village near
Sopore by some miscreants belonging to Army backed renegade outfit
Ikhwan-ul-Muslimoon. The Jammu and Kashmir Police accompanied the
leader, caught hold of some renegades and snatched their rifles.

Rashtriya Rifles personnel, the security agency patronizing the
renegades camping nearby were out raged at the police action and
dragged all the leaders out of their cars. The leaders were beaten
severely. Mr. Abdul Gani Lone and Mr. Shabir Ahmad Shah were injured
Abdul Ahad Waza was beaten and injured. He was hospitalized on his
return to Srinagar from Sopore; a bomb was thrown on the car carrying
Syed A1i Shah Geelani at Narbal near Srinagar. The Bomb hit the escort
Car damaging its windscreen. Those traveling by car escaped unhurt.
The police recovered four landmines from the spot.

9.May 9, 1996: 40 gunmen entered into residence of the Syed Ali
Geelani but the guards strongly resisted their entry. Meanwhile the
police reached on spot but allowed these gunmen to leave the area
without questioning their motives.

10.May 16, 1996: Rocket attack on Hyderpora official residence. The
rocket exploded near the main gate. The local police recovered another
unexploded rocket.

11.May 17, 1996: Another grenade attack within less than 36 hours
exploded near the outer wall damaging it. Eyewitness said that they
saw security vehicle in the area minutes before the explosion. No one
was injured.
12.June 8, 1996: Indian Army and their agent’s showered nine grenades
and hundreds of bullets at 11 P.M on the residential house of Syed Ali
Shah Geelani at Hyderpora Srinagar.

13.Oct. 13/14, 1996: The house of Syed Ali Shah Geelani was again
attacked and fired upon from the main airport road. The firing
continued for about thirty minutes. The bullets hit the main gate and
other parts of the outer wall of the building.

14.March 12, 1999: The All Parties Hurriyat Conference (APHC)
Chairman, Syed Ali Geelani and his associates were attacked by dozens
of armed youth in a local hotel City Heart Hari Market Jammu late in
the evening. The incident took place at about 9.45 P.M.

15.September 7, 1999: The APHC chairman Syed A1i Geelani and his
associates were attacked by BSF-I72 Btn. Led by Inspector Rajiv
Kumaran main Chowk Kulengam Handwara while addressing election boycottrally.

16.September 8, 1999: On the same day they were subjected to another
attack by STF led by Inspector Sharma at Kulengam Handwara at 8. P.M
he had narrow escape when a bullet hit a near by wall and also the
tier of Geelani’s car.

17.On 30th June, 2000: The Chairman of the Hurriyat Conference Syed Ali Geelani and his associates had a narrow escape when they wereassaulted by the army personnel on their return from Magam Handwara.
The Incident occurred when Hurriyat leaders were proceeding to’
village after addressing a rally at Magam Handwara Kupwara.
This is the brief chronology up to 30th June 2000. If this could
happen with a prominent leader of Jammu and Kashmir one can imagine
the plight of masses over there.

We appeal to the world community to take note of the situation and
attacks on the life and property of the civil and political activists.

Ayaz Akbar
Spokesman
All Parties Hurriyat Conference Jammu and Kashmir

Monday, 14 November 2011

101 Reasons Indian Security Forces Make Our Lives Miserable In Kashmir

BY; LONESOME KASHMIRI
  1. By Having Their Guns pointed at us all the time.
  2. By looking at us with suspicion all the time.
  3. By Making us Show our Identification every 100 meters.
  4. By Occupying our Orchards, Schools and Houses.
  5. By shooting at us and taking sick pleasure from it.
  6. By beating us while we play cricket in the field.
  7. By making us sit in cold, hot weather and rain when they search our villages and towns.
  8. By burning our property. In One instance they burnt down the entire Iqbal Market of Sopore.
  9. By looting our valuables.
  10. By Killing young innocent young people.
  11. By consistently reminding us of their presence with their whistles and bamboo sticks.
  12. By making us wait on the road for hours while their convoys are passing through.
  13. By taking our vehicles whenever they want and sometimes keeping it with them for as long as they like.
  14. By torturing us without any reason.
  15. By arresting us without any warrant, proof or valid reason.
  16. By forcibly taking our apples and other crops and not paying for it.
  17. By ruining our forests and natural resources.
  18. By having our deposit my identity card at the camp when I visit my sister’s place.
  19. By having our walk almost a mile to the main gates of the army camp when we enter our own villages.
  20. By having us record our names, addresses and telephone numbers even when I go inside my village.
  21. By having to answer the army what I am doing in my own house.
  22. By not being able to walk alone when I leave my house and have to go through a road where there is an army camp.
  23. By making us run errands for them as if we are their servants.
  24. By desecrating our religious places.
  25. By entering our homes and showing no regard for our privacy.
  26. By extorting money from us on various false allegations.
  27. By making our young boys addicted to drugs and alcohol.
  28. By embarrassing our elders and showing them no respect.
  29. By Making us do forced labor for years and years.
  30. By staging fake encounters.
  31. By commiting custodial killings.
  32. By wreaking havoc after grenade attack or firing incidents.
  33. By haunting the steps of our sisters in Kashmir.
  34. By blaming us for imaginary crimes.
  35. By cordoning off the entire villages and not even allowing people to have a sip of water.
  36. By forcing us to hoist Indian flags when we do not want to.
  37. By forcing us to vote in elections when we do not want to.
  38. By supporting anti-social activities and anti-social people.
  39. By Making us go through an identification parade at every army camp we pass on our way.
  40. By summoning the parents and relatives of Militants to army camps as if they were some petty criminals.
  41. By occupying every bridge and bank of rivers.
  42. By resorting to psychological torture when physical torture does not seem enough for them.
  43. By not allowing us to particpate in our religious duties.
  44. By having us use only lanterns and not torches or electric lamps when go out in the night.
  45. By Not allowing us to pray in the Mosques.
  46. By not allowing us to voice our protests.
  47. By not listening to us and instead torture us some more.
  48. By having to explain to the army why am I walking, running, Sleeping, Eating or even breathing.
  49. By forcing us to carry multiple identifications all the time. And then not honoring them.
  50. By making our take longer routes so I can avoid the army bunkers.
  51. By having those hated military bunkers in every nook and corner of the valley.
  52. By acting superior to us even though most of them are illiterate.
  53. By constructing third rate Bus stands and sub-standard schools which endanger everybody.
  54. By making Highways “One ways”.
  55. By not allowing us to celebrate our religious festivals.
  56. By not failing to summon the groom on the day of his wedding.
  57. By making our hit my friends at gunpoint.
  58. By taking everything from our including my pride.
  59. By polluting our fresh water bodies.
  60. By chopping down pine trees to make furniture for their homes.
  61. By colluding with Government agents and destroying the cultural fabric of Kashmir.
  62. By making us mentally sick with their presence.
  63. By diluting our faith by bringing sins of alcohol, cinema etc. with them.
  64. By making our places of worship inaccessible to us.
  65. By using us as their shields in encounters.
  66. By haunting the steps of our sisters.
  67. By having us clean the blood of our brothers from the road.
  68. By erecting Hindu temples in our localities.
  69. By establishing circles and circles of barricades around your camps and making even our walking difficult.
  70. By showing arrogance when offered water and they throwing the utensils to ground.
  71. By talking obscenely to our elders and ladies.
  72. By showing no regard to our sentiments and feelings regarding our history and religion.
  73. By kidnapping people as if they do not matter.
  74. By acting as police, Lawyers and Judges all by themselves.
  75. By making us feel insignificant and unimportant.
  76. By making our take permission from them for a wedding party even though it is my village, my home.
  77. By Imposing restrictions on my movement any time they want.
  78. By Making my mother and sisters cry every time they abduct our to their army camp.
  79. By torturing relatives if there is a militant in the family. Does not matter even if that militant is not a close relative.
  80. By refusing our passport again and again and again by giving negative verification reports.
  81. By humiliating children in front of their parents and humiliating parents in front of their children.
  82. By committing heinous crimes and then blaming them on us.
  83. By frisking our every time I go into a government office.
  84. By having to go through endless security checks at the airport.
  85. By making our small children frightened by their hateful stares and abuses.
  86. By hitting our young small children with rifle butts.
  87. By making our hospitals places for them to practice.
  88. By not allowing ambulances which carry critical patients.
  89. By not allowing us to bury our dead with respect and honor.
  90. By suffocating us with their alcoholic habits.
  91. By making our young boys shameless and characterless.
  92. By using 100′s of mortars to defeat one single militant and in the process destroying dozens of homes.
  93. By coming in the dead of the night and harassing our religious figures.
  94. By beating our Imams and Muezzins.
  95. By showing no remorse when they desecrate the Quran ul Kareem.
  96. By forcing us to shout “Jai Hind” when I don’t want to.
  97. By forcibly making our say ‘Hey Ram” and Hindu Shloks when I hate to say it.
  98. By asking our questions for which I have no answers.
  99. By trying to sabotage any peace initiative in Villages.
  100. By Making us lose our sanity with constant crackdowns and actions.
  101. By simply being there all the time.

Unmarked Graves Give Up Their Shameful Secrets


By: Ben Doherty


Every village has stories of men and boys taken from their homes and never seen again, writes Ben Doherty in northern Kashmir.


The police bring the bodies. In the day or night they bring them, wrapped loosely in blankets or in the clothes they wore. ''The bodies come in very bad condition,'' Nizar Ahmed Mir tells the Herald through an interpreter, standing on the steep slopes of the Shaheed cemetery at the end of a narrow dirt road. ''They are bloody, some are in handcuffs, the clothing is torn. Most have been shot in the face, or the face has been damaged, so they cannot be identified. We don't know who they are, we are just told to bury them.''


Nizar lives in the town of Kupwara, in northern Kashmir, on the edge of one of the most restive regions of the valley.


He farms for a living, but besides that, is one of the men the police come to with bodies. He is one of Kashmir's reluctant, but compelled, gravediggers.


Many of the bodies are incomplete, Nizar says, missing hands or limbs. Sometimes police just bring a head, handing it over with the same instruction: ''Bury this''. The dead are all men.

The police didn't kill them. The army did. The police are the intermediaries and they have as little information as they pass on.


''The police bring the bodies, they say: 'The army gave them to us, they are militants killed in gunfight'. But we don't know who they are. There are no documents and the police don't want questions.


''We cannot argue with the police; we do not ask who they were, or how they died. We just bury them, like we are told.''


It is true that some of the bodies are those of militant soldiers, killed resisting the Indian military and police presence around the disputed line of control between the Indian- and Pakistan-controlled Kashmir.


But every village in Kashmir carries stories of night-time invasions of homes by heavily armed soldiers, of men and boys taken away, never to be seen again, of people shot in the street and their deaths restaged to appear as though they occurred in battle. These are Kashmir's so-called ''fake encounters''.


Civil rights groups such as Association of Parents of Disappeared Persons estimate there are about 8000 men missing in Kashmir, disappeared over two decades of conflict. It appears now they might finally be found.


The bodies being uncovered in these graves are, almost certainly, those men. And for the first time, an Indian state government has admitted - albeit unwittingly and unwillingly - to Kashmir's worst-kept secret.


A leaked report by the State Human Rights Commission in Indian-controlled Kashmir has conceded ''it is beyond doubt that unmarked graves containing unidentified bodies do exist … in North Kashmir. There is every probability that these … graves … contain the bodies of enforced disappearances.''


The report said 2730 unidentified bodies had been found in Kashmiri soil and, through cursory efforts at identification, found that 574 of them were not foreign militants as claimed, but local men, killed and buried in secret. It has called for DNA testing of all of the unidentified bodies and said of government resistance to formal identification ''it has to be presumed the state wants to remain silent deliberately to hide the human rights violations''.


Built on a steep slope of land unusable for anything else, the Shaheed, the Urdu word for martyr, graveyard in Kupwara has only five graves that are marked with headstones. About a dozen more have small stone cairns pushed into the ground, some daubed with a painted number.

The number correlates only to the order a person was known to be buried.


While it appears there are about 20 bodies in the ground here, Nizar said there are more than 200 people buried in this narrow, steep wedge of land.


Some of the unmarked graves are apparent only because they have collapsed, leaving gaping holes. Of the others, there is no sign, and no record.


The Shaheed cemetery was full in less than three years, and bodies brought to Kupwara now are taken elsewhere.


About a kilometre away is Rigipura graveyard. It is also on a disused hillside, its graves packed in tight rows, a couple with names, more with numbers, but most completely unmarked save for the tell-tale disturbance of the earth.


Near a grove of walnut trees, the Herald is approached by a bricklayer who gives his name as Ghulam. He says that he, too, has been forced to bury bodies by police. ''Here,'' he walks to a bare patch of earth near the fence and points down.


''Here I had to bury a head. Two months before. No body. Just a head. I did not know who it was.''

He says all the bodies he has been made to bury have had their faces disfigured. None have been identifiable.


''Yes, I believe they are forced disappearances, the fake encounters.''


Publicly, at least, the government of Jammu and Kashmir is maintaining the bodies are those of militants killed in combat against the Indian military or as they tried to illegally cross the Line of Control into Pakistan to receive arms training.


The chief of army in Jammu and Kashmir, Lieutenant General Syed Ata Hasnain, declined an interview with the Herald, but the Chief Minister, Omar Abdullah, told the state assembly his government would investigate all the unmarked graves and has proposed a truth and reconciliation commission ''for the people of the state''.


But he warned that investigations would take time, and that the conflict in Kashmir was not black and white.


''We are not here to hide the facts or conceal the truth … but our endeavour is to dig out the facts and bring these before the public. This cannot be done overnight but we have to make a start in this direction.''


Mr Abdullah said it was unfair to blame security forces for all of the deaths in Kashmir.

''I can say with authority that some of the persons buried in these unmarked graves were killed by the militants,'' he said.


Mr Abdullah denied there were any mass graves in Kashmir. But his government's own human rights watchdog disagrees, and is damning of security forces.


The human rights commission accuses the police of falsifying claims about how people died, and says it found mass graves in the valley.


The commission's report also says there are almost certainly more secret gravesites in the valley.

Since 1988, the violence in Kashmir has claimed more than 43,000 lives.


Jana Begum knows the cost of those lost lives. Five of them belonged to her family.


In half a decade, she lost her husband and four sons to Kashmir's violence. Two of her sons were picked up by police in Kupwara. Eighteen days later she was told her sons were buried in the Rigipura cemetery.


Her husband was seized by authorities in a midnight raid and taken into custody. Six months later he emerged, so badly beaten he survived only one day at home.


''He was so unwell, he was unable to eat anything. We were feeding him milk in a spoon, but we could not stop him from dying. He died because of the interrogation,'' she said.


Another son was shot through an open window in the family home, while another simply vanished while he was studying at an Islamic school in Deoband. His body has never been found.

Jana Begum sits in the bare front room of her house.


Speaking barely above a whisper, she points out the bullet holes in the window frames. The same bullets, she says, took her son.


She holds a picture of the family she lost, and says she believes her family was targeted because her husband was an imam and her sons went to religious schools to study the Koran.


''The militants came to our house and demanded that my family join them, but they refused,'' she said. ''But people see the militants enter our home and they think we are working for them. We did not. We were never part of that. Not ever.''


The loss of the men in her family has left her destitute.


''During festivals like Eid, I go to Srinagar, to beg for money from people. I have no other way, no choice. My whole family is destroyed by these terrible incidents.''


Jana Begum has no interest in peace in the valley. She doesn't believe it will come, and she no longer cares.


''The people who did this, they took my sons and my husband,'' she said.


''I have no interest in anything they do now. They cannot give me my family back.''

Army Made 18 Assassination Bids On My Life, Claims Geelani

Alleging that the Army has made "18 assassination bids” on his life since 1996, Chairman Hurriyat Conference (G), Syed Ali Shah Geelani, Monday said the Army man caught with a pistol at his rally in Sopore last Friday had been sent to "murder him or cause a stampede by firing".

Addressing a press conference at his Hyderpora residence, Geelani said that his party has lodged a complaint with the Sopore police for FIR against the army.

“There could have been only two motives for the Army to send its armed man in civvies to our peaceful rally: either it wanted to eliminate me or cause a stampede hoping that it would prove fatal for me or the common people present there. Later, the police would have blamed the militants for the attack,” Geelani said.

Geelani said the Sopore incident was the 18th attempt on his life by army , beginning with a rocket attack on his Hyderpora residence in 1996. “After the rocket attack, an army officer called one of our neighbours and asked if I had died in the attack,” Geelani said.

“He used the words ‘Kya Kute ki Dukan Band Hogayi (Has the dog been finished?)” Geelani alleged.

Geelani said the ID card recovered from the man caught by people at his rally identified him as Naik Kamlesh Kumar Mishra.

“I told the people to hand him over to the police but instead of registering an FIR against him, the police has registered a case against dozen innocent youth from Sopore who were present at the peaceful rally,” Geelani said.

Geelani said he was aware of the presence of “agencies” at his rallies or gatherings but the Sopore incident was “a deep-rooted conspiracy to eliminate him.”

“We know there are people from different Indian agencies and police at our rallies, but I am never bothered about it because my stand on end to Indian occupation is unambiguous and known to all. However, the Sopore incident was a well-planned conspiracy to eliminate me,” he said.

He said the matter should be probed to “unveil inhumane and shameful attitude of Indian army in Kashmir."

Geelani alleged that the army wanted to repeat “another January 6, 1993 when 40 people were burnt alive and 200 houses and shops gutted by the forces after a youth snatched the gun of one of their personnel.”

“The army has developed a lust for power in Kashmir and is acting as the government here, with both the civil administration and police being under its thumb,” Geelani said, adding that Kashmir “has become a killing field for the army.”

Geelani said the army was trying to make inroads into educational institutes as well and "brave students must resist this intrusion.”

"I appeal students to be brave and tell these army officers and generals on their face that they have no right to be deliver lectures in our schools and colleges after killing, disappearing thousands of Kashmiris, burning houses and unleashing worst human rights violations on us,” he said.

In response to a query on the statement of former cricketer and Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf chief, Imran Khan’s statement that Pakistan should put Kashmir issue on the “back burner”, Geelani said the country should stand firm on its “principled stand on Kashmir.”





|Kashmir Dispatch|